Are Vintage Cherry Switches Better?
Are Vintage Cherry Switches Better?
Switch enthusiasts often engage in fervent debates over the quality and performance of different mechanical keyboard switches. In particular, vintage Cherry switches have achieved an almost legendary status among keyboard aficionados. But are they truly superior to modern alternatives? This blog post delves into the characteristics of vintage Cherry switches, assessing them across several categories such as smoothness, weighting, sound, typing, and gaming performance. We’ll provide a comprehensive scoring system that offers an objective evaluation, helping you decide if these switches are worth the hype. Additionally, we’ll guide you on where you might be able to find these venerable switches and some modern alternatives if you’re on the hunt for a specific feel or performance.
TL;DR
If you are looking for a quick takeaway, vintage Cherry switches provide a unique nostalgic charm but may not be everyone’s cup of tea, especially when considering the advances made in more modern switches. They have an overall score of 56%, which signals that while they have historical value, they might not excel in every technical category. For those interested in the rich heritage of keyboard switches, vintage Cherry remains a collector’s dream. However, if performance is a higher priority, modern switches might offer more bang for your buck.
Smoothness: 4/10
Smoothness is one of the most sought-after qualities in a mechanical keyboard switch, influencing the overall typing experience. Vintage Cherry switches, particularly those from the early batches, are often noted for their distinctive smoothness. However, compared to modern switches that use advanced manufacturing processes and materials, vintage Cherry switches might feel slightly scratchier. This is especially true for those switches that have seen extensive use over the years.
Despite the nostalgic appeal, vintage switches have inherent limitations due to their age. Dust and wear can affect their performance over time. While lubing can restore some of their lost smoothness, it often falls short of achieving the polish you might find in newly designed switches. Therefore, while vintage Cherry switches hold a certain charm, they may not match the standard set by current smooth models such as the Gateron or the newer Cherry MX line.
Weighting: 6/10
Weighting refers to the force required to press a key and plays a crucial role in determining the typing feel. Vintage Cherry switches provide a consistent weighting experience, which is a quality many users appreciate. These switches often possess a medium actuation force that recent linear and tactile switches have tried to emulate, albeit with a more modern twist.
However, the weighting might not be ideal for everyone. Contemporary switches offer customizable options that allow users to select from a wide range of actuation forces, whereas vintage Cherry switches are somewhat standard. This lack of variety could be a deal-breaker for those looking to tailor their switch force to their specific needs. Nevertheless, for purists, the original Cherry weighting feels just right.
Sound: 6/10
The sound produced by Cherry switches is often considered music to the ears of keyboard enthusiasts. Vintage Cherry switches, with their characteristic soft clack, add an element of nostalgia to the typing experience. This acoustic profile is appreciated by some for its subtlety and precision but might be too subdued for those who enjoy a more pronounced sound.
In comparison, modern switches like the Kailh BOX or NovelKeys Cream offer more deliberate auditory feedback, accommodating users who prefer louder, more tactile sounds. The sound quality of vintage Cherry switches can also vary based on their condition and maintenance, presenting an inconsistent experience unless the user undertakes significant effort in refurbishing older chains.
Typing Performance: 5/10
A comfortable typing experience is often predicated on the balance of smoothness, weighting, and sound. Vintage Cherry switches offer a decent typing performance, particularly for enthusiasts who have adapted to the feedback and rhythm of these classic switches over years of use. However, for newcomers, they may not provide the most fluid typing experience without specific adjustments such as spring swapping or lubrication.
The consistency of keystroke registration in vintage switches might also be challenged by wear and micro-level irregularities developed over time. Modern switches with competitive manufacturing precision and innovative mechanisms can, in many cases, outperform vintage models in terms of reliability and comfort during prolonged typing sessions.
Gaming Performance: 7/10
When it comes to gaming, switch performance is paramount. Vintage Cherry switches offer a relatively good gaming experience thanks to their reliable actuation points. They were initially designed for professional and corporate environments but have proven their worth in gaming scenarios due to their build stability and responsiveness.
However, today’s gaming demands are higher, with a focus on faster, quieter, and more diverse gaming-oriented switches. The competition from specifically designed gaming switches such as the Razer Optical or Cherry MX Speed has created a more substantial gap between vintage gaming performance and modern standards. Nonetheless, for those who appreciate traditional switch mechanisms, vintage Cherry still holds its ground.
Final Score = 28/50 (56%)
In summary, vintage Cherry switches score decently across various performance metrics, finishing with an overall score of 56%. They bring a unique blend of nostalgia and authenticity that appeals to loyalists and collectors. However, for those valuing top-tier performance and customization, modern switches might be better suited to fulfill their needs. As with many vintage items, Cherry switches offer an experience anchored in history, often trading off some performance aspects for character and legacy.
Places to purchase this switch:
If you’re committed to acquiring vintage Cherry switches, online marketplaces like eBay and specialty keyboard forums are good starting points. These platforms often host sellers who specialize in vintage keyboard components, giving you the chance to find specific switch types that you’re interested in.
Purchasing an Akko switch? (Affiliate Link)
For those considering an alternative, Akko switches offer a modern twist with an emphasis on smoothness and affordability.
Check out these Akko switches
for a modern equivalent that maintains high performance standards without sacrificing too much of the nostalgic charm.
Support me on Ko-fi 💜
If you find this review helpful and want to support my work, consider
buying me a coffee on Ko-fi
. Your support means a lot and helps me continue to create in-depth content about all things mechanical keyboards.
Macho/Banana Split
Among other modern equivalents, Macho and Banana Split switches represent a new generation of mechanical switches that offer a smooth tactile feel paired with a pleasing auditory profile. While they don’t mimic the exact characteristics of vintage Cherry switches, they are popular options among those looking for a reliable and enjoyable typing experience.
Kailh BOX Pink
The Kailh BOX Pink switches provide another solid alternative. Known for their durability and unique tactile feedback, these switches rival vintage models’ qualities while offering enhanced resilience to dust and water. Their distinct design is favored by gamers and typists alike and is a compelling choice for those who appreciate innovation in switch technology.
Summary of Main Points
| Aspect | Score | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Smoothness | 4/10 | Charming but not as polished as modern offerings |
| Weighting | 6/10 | Consistent but lacks variety for customization |
| Sound | 6/10 | Subtle and classic, may need maintenance for consistency |
| Typing Performance | 5/10 | Decent but can falter with age and use |
| Gaming Performance | 7/10 | Good reliability, though modern switches are catching up |
| Overall Score | 28/50 | Valuable for collectors, decent but not leading in performance |


