Kailh Speed Silver vs Cherry MX Speed Silver: A Comprehensive Review
Kailh Speed Silver vs Cherry MX Speed Silver: A Comprehensive Review
Switches are the heart of any mechanical keyboard, directly affecting your typing and gaming experience. Two popular choices among enthusiasts are the Kailh Speed Silver and Cherry MX Speed Silver. Both are designed for fast action but differ in key aspects. This blog post examines these differences, focusing on aspects like smoothness, weighting, sound, and performance both in typing and gaming. If you’re considering these switches, this guide will help you determine which might best suit your needs.
TL;DR
In a nutshell, the Kailh Speed Silver and Cherry MX Speed Silver switches are both designed for speed, with slight differences in feel, sound, and performance. While neither excels significantly over the other, individual preferences may tilt your choice. This post scores them on smoothness, weighting, sound, typing, and gaming prowess to aid your switch decision.
Smoothness: 4/10
Smoothness in switches refers to the ease of actuation and the absence of friction during keypresses. Both Kailh Speed Silver and Cherry MX Speed Silver aim to deliver quick responses, but their performance is somewhat underwhelming in terms of smoothness. Users report that while both switches offer a rapid keystroke response, they sometimes feel a slight scratchiness, especially noticeable in initial usage periods.
Kailh’s offering tends to have a slightly smoother glide after a break-in period compared to its Cherry counterpart. The switch’s construction and quality control process seem to prioritize longevity over immediate out-of-the-box smoothness. Thus, potential buyers might experience a brief adaptation period before noticing the switch’s full smooth potential.
Weighting: 4/10
Weighting determines how much force is required to depress the key, impacting both typing speed and fatigue. The Kailh Speed Silver and Cherry MX Speed Silver are both marketed as lightweight, yet neither drastically outperforms the other in this regard. They each feature an actuation force of around 45g, promoting quick keypresses without the additional strain of heavier switches.
However, users accustomed to other lightweight switches might not find a significant reduction in force requirements. Some users notice a slight heaviness in prolonged gaming or typing sessions, which is somewhat unexpected for switches of their category. This is an area where both switches maintain a balance between responsiveness and comfort, but neither stands out distinctly.
Sound: 4/10
The sound produced by a mechanical switch is crucial for both personal satisfaction and workplace acceptance. Kailh and Cherry switches produce similar auditory feedback, with the Speed Silvers noted for a modest click, rather than a thundering clack found in other switch types. This makes them suitable choices for quieter environments or shared spaces.
In direct comparison, the Kailh switch exhibits a slightly sharper sound profile, whereas the Cherry switch tends to emit a deeper tone. Sound preferences are subjective, but neither switch is likely to be too disruptive. The quieter nature may appeal to users preferring less noise without sacrificing the feel of a mechanical keyboard.
Typing Performance: 4/10
Both switches cater to users who value speed and efficiency over tactile feedback. The linear travel path and fast actuation make both switches capable typers, although they lack the tactile cues some typists appreciate. On long essays or extensive data entry, users might miss the tactile feedback, potentially leading to more errors.
Moreover, the typing performance doesn’t drastically deviate between the two. Each offers quick actuation and reliable performance, though some users find Kailh to have a slight edge in providing a comfortable long-term typing experience, possibly due to its marginally smoother operation post-break-in.
Gaming Performance: 4/10
Performance in gaming is where these switches were designed to excel. Their hallmark is responsiveness, purportedly increasing a gamer’s edge in competitive scenarios. Both Kailh Speed Silver and Cherry MX Speed Silver serve this purpose well, offering high actuation speed and low force requirements.
Despite this, some gamers report minimal disparity in performance boost over other switches, attributing greater gameplay influence to skill rather than hardware. Ultimately, while both switches support gaming needs effectively, they may not provide the significant advantage one might expect in top-tier competitive settings.
Final Score = 20/50 (40%)
Both Kailh Speed Silver and Cherry MX Speed Silver fulfill their promises to deliver speed, yet fall short if compared based on smoothness, weighting, and sound. They are efficient for gamers looking for quick actuation, but without the excitement one might expect from switches branded for speed. That said, the choice largely hinges on individual preferences around sound profile and post-break-in smoothness.
Places to purchase this switch:
These switches can be found across a variety of online platforms, including Amazon, Newegg, and specialist mechanical keyboard stores. Always ensure you’re purchasing from a reputable source to avoid counterfeits.
Purchasing an Akko switch? (Affiliate Link)
If you’re considering diversifying your switch collection, Akko offers a robust line of tactile and linear switches. Purchasing through affiliate links can support reviewers like myself without additional cost to you.
Buy Akko Switches Here
.
Support me on Ko-fi 💜
Your support helps me dive deeper into the world of mechanical keyboards and deliver more content! If you appreciate these detailed comparisons, consider supporting me on
Ko-fi
.
KiiBOOM Taro Cream Milk
For those interested in branching out, the KiiBOOM Taro Cream Milk offers another unique typing experience. Known for its smoothness and gentle sound, it might intrigue users seeking something different from the classic speed-focused switches.
Kailh BOX Speed Ultimate.
The Kailh BOX Speed Ultimate takes the Speed Silver concept further, aiming for enhanced durability and consistent performance. If you’re seeking something robust with a bit more oomph, this might be worth exploring.
Final Thoughts
| Criteria | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Smoothness | 4/10 | Slightly scratchy initially, smoother after break-in. |
| Weighting | 4/10 | Efficient for quick keypresses, potential for slight fatigue over time. |
| Sound | 4/10 | Modest sound profile, suitable for quieter environments. |
| Typing Performance | 4/10 | Quick actuation but lacks tactile feedback. |
| Gaming Performance | 4/10 | Good for quick actuation, but marginal performance boost perceived. |
| Overall | 20/50 (40%) | Competent yet unremarkable switches; preference-dependent choice. |
